Skip to main content
U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Dot gov

The .gov means it’s official.
Federal government websites often end in .gov or .mil. Before sharing sensitive information, make sure you’re on a federal government site.

Https

The site is secure.
The https:// ensures that you are connecting to the official website and that any information you provide is encrypted and transmitted securely.

National Evaluation of Welfare-to-Work Strategies: 2-Year Client Survey Files: Annotated tables display key outcomes of respondent and household income

                                                         Table 7.3                                 Program Impacts on Employment Status of Respondent and                                Other Household Members in the Last Month of Follow-Up                                                  Sample Program Control Difference    Percentage Site and Program                                  Size   Group   Group   (Impact)    Change (%)                                                       Only respondent employed (%)  Atlanta Labor Force Attachment                     1890    31.8    27.8     4.1  **      14.7     EORYOHHN Atlanta Human Capital Development                  2199    28.2    27.8     0.4           1.5     EORYOHHN  Grand Rapids Labor Force Attachment                1158    37.7    32.8     4.9  *       15.0     EORYOHHN Grand Rapids Human Capital Development             1158    33.9    32.8     1.1           3.2     EORYOHHN  Riverside Labor Force Attachment                   1678    28.4    22.4     5.9  ***     26.5     EORYOHHN   Lacked high school diploma or basic skills       1012    25.7    18.4     7.4  ***     40.2     EORYOHHN Riverside Human Capital Development                1350    25.7    18.4     7.4  ***     40.1     EORYOHHN  Columbus Integrated                                 728    37.6    27.4    10.2  ***     37.1     EORYOHHN Columbus Traditional                                723    31.5    27.4     4.1          14.9     EORYOHHN  Detroit                                             426    33.8    28.3     5.5          19.4     EORYOHHN  Oklahoma City                                       511    30.2    28.9     1.3           4.5     EORYOHHN  Portland                                            610    32.5    21.6    10.9  ***     50.5     EORYOHHN                                                   Only other household members employed (%)  Atlanta Labor Force Attachment                     1890     8.5    11.7    -3.2  **     -27.2     EORNOHHY Atlanta Human Capital Development                  2199     9.6    11.7    -2.1         -17.6     EORNOHHY  Grand Rapids Labor Force Attachment                1158    13.7    12.6     1.1           8.8     EORNOHHY Grand Rapids Human Capital Development             1158    11.8    12.6    -0.8          -6.2     EORNOHHY  Riverside Labor Force Attachment                   1678    17.6    18.6    -1.1          -5.7     EORNOHHY   Lacked high school diploma or basic skills       1012    19.6    19.8    -0.2          -1.1     EORNOHHY Riverside Human Capital Development                1350    19.6    19.8    -0.2          -1.0     EORNOHHY  Columbus Integrated                                 728    10.8    14.4    -3.6         -25.0     EORNOHHY Columbus Traditional                                723    12.2    14.4    -2.2         -15.0     EORNOHHY  Detroit                                             426     4.5     8.6    -4.0         -47.1     EORNOHHY  Oklahoma City                                       511    15.2    21.2    -6.0  *      -28.3     EORNOHHY  Portland                                            610    19.3    23.6    -4.4         -18.5     EORNOHHY                                                                                                 (continued)                                                          Table 7.3 (continued)                                                            Program Control Difference   Percentage Site and Program                                         Group   Group   (Impact)   Change (%)                                                         Respondent and other household                                                        members employed (%)  Atlanta Labor Force Attachment                              7.6     8.6    -0.9         -11.0     EORYOHHY Atlanta Human Capital Development                           8.9     8.6     0.4           4.3     EORYOHHY  Grand Rapids Labor Force Attachment                        18.8    18.6     0.2           1.1     EORYOHHY Grand Rapids Human Capital Development                     19.2    18.6     0.6           3.5     EORYOHHY  Riverside Labor Force Attachment                           14.2    13.0     1.2           9.2     EORYOHHY   Lacked high school diploma or basic skills               11.8    10.1     1.7          16.7     EORYOHHY Riverside Human Capital Development                        11.2    10.1     1.1          10.6     EORYOHHY  Columbus Integrated                                        14.3    13.2     1.1           8.5     EORYOHHY Columbus Traditional                                       14.5    13.2     1.3          10.2     EORYOHHY  Detroit                                                     9.7     5.8     3.9          67.8     EORYOHHY  Oklahoma City                                              18.6    19.4    -0.9          -4.4     EORYOHHY  Portland                                                   17.6    13.1     4.5          33.9     EORYOHHY                                                         Respondent and other household                                                        members not employed (%)  Atlanta Labor Force Attachment                             52.0    52.0     0.0           0.1     eornohhn Atlanta Human Capital Development                          53.2    52.0     1.3           2.4     eornohhn  Grand Rapids Labor Force Attachment                        29.8    36.0    -6.2   **    -17.3     eornohhn Grand Rapids Human Capital Development                     35.1    36.0    -0.9          -2.6     eornohhn Riverside Labor Force Attachment                           39.9    46.0    -6.1  ***    -13.2     eornohhn   Lacked high school diploma or basic skills               42.9    51.7    -8.9  ***    -17.1     eornohhn Riverside Human Capital Development                        43.5    51.7    -8.2  ***    -15.9     eornohhn  Columbus Integrated                                        37.3    45.0    -7.7   **    -17.1     eornohhn Columbus Traditional                                       41.8    45.0    -3.3          -7.3     eornohhn  Detroit                                                    52.0    57.4    -5.4          -9.4     eornohhn  Oklahoma City                                              36.0    30.5     5.6          18.3     eornohhn  Portland                                                   30.7    41.6   -11.0  ***    -26.4     eornohhn 

 


 

                                           Table 7.2              Program Impacts on Total Respondent Income in the Last Month of Follow-Up                                                   Sample Program Control Difference   Percentage Site and Program                                   Size   Group   Group   (Impact)   Change (%)                                                  Total measured respondent income ($)  Atlanta Labor Force Attachment                      1890     691     669      22          3.3     INCTOT2 Atlanta Human Capital Development                   2199     699     669      30 *        4.4     INCTOT2  Grand Rapids Labor Force Attachment                 1158     791     828     -37         -4.5     INCTOT2 Grand Rapids Human Capital Development              1158     793     828     -35         -4.2     INCTOT2  Riverside Labor Force Attachment                    1678     879     860      19          2.2     INCTOT2   Lacked high school diploma or basic skills        1012     854     851       4          0.4     INCTOT2 Riverside Human Capital Development                 1350     845     851      -5         -0.6     INCTOT2  Columbus Integrated                                  728     770     778      -7         -0.9     INCTOT2 Columbus Traditional                                 723     793     778      15          2.0     INCTOT2  Detroit                                              426     782     764      18          2.4     INCTOT2  Oklahoma City                                        511     671     706     -35         -5.0     INCTOT2  Portland                                             610     891     834      57          6.8     INCTOT2                                                  Respondent earnings as a percentage of                                                 total measured income (%)  Atlanta Labor Force Attachment                      1890    29.8    26.5     3.3 *       12.4     SVERNP2 Atlanta Human Capital Development                   2199    27.9    26.5     1.4          5.3     SVERNP2  Grand Rapids Labor Force Attachment                 1158    42.0    36.3     5.7 **      15.7     SVERNP2 Grand Rapids Human Capital Development              1158    38.6    36.3     2.3          6.4     SVERNP2  Riverside Labor Force Attachment                    1678    29.9    23.5     6.4 ***     27.1     SVERNP2   Lacked high school diploma or basic skills        1012    25.6    18.7     6.9 ***     37.1     SVERNP2 Riverside Human Capital Development                 1350    23.9    18.7     5.3 **      28.3     SVERNP2  Columbus Integrated                                  728    41.3    31.9     9.4 ***     29.4     SVERNP2 Columbus Traditional                                 723    34.6    31.9     2.7          8.4     SVERNP2  Detroit                                              426    31.0    21.4     9.5 ***     44.3     SVERNP2  Oklahoma City                                        511    37.6    38.1    -0.5         -1.3     SVERNP2  Portland                                             610    38.5    26.2    12.2 ***     46.6     SVERNP2                                                                                     (continued)                                            Table 7.2  (continued)                                                           Program Control Difference Percentage Site and Program                                         Group   Group (Impact)   Change (%)                                                  Total measured respondent net income ($)  Atlanta Labor Force Attachment                           723     699      24          3.4         INCTOT3 Atlanta Human Capital Development                        725     699      26          3.7         INCTOT3  Grand Rapids Labor Force Attachment                      792     833     -42         -5.0         INCTOT3 Grand Rapids Human Capital Development                   805     833     -28         -3.4         INCTOT3  Riverside Labor Force Attachment                         886     867      19          2.2         INCTOT3   Lacked high school diploma or basic skills             864     859       5          0.6         INCTOT3 Riverside Human Capital Development                      849     859     -10         -1.2         INCTOT3  Columbus Integrated                                      797     806      -9         -1.1         INCTOT3 Columbus Traditional                                     823     806      17          2.1         INCTOT3  Detroit                                                  776     766      10          1.3         INCTOT3  Oklahoma City                                            697     737     -40         -5.4         INCTOT3  Portland                                                 902     843      59          7.0         INCTOT3                                                  Total measured respondent net income                                                 at or above the poverty level (%)  Atlanta Labor Force Attachment                          21.1    19.9     1.2          6.0         SI3100M Atlanta Human Capital Development                       20.5    19.9     0.6          3.1         SI3100M  Grand Rapids Labor Force Attachment                     31.7    31.4     0.4          1.2         SI3100M Grand Rapids Human Capital Development                  31.3    31.4    -0.1         -0.2         SI3100M  Riverside Labor Force Attachment                        33.6    27.4     6.3 ***     22.8         SI3100M   Lacked high school diploma or basic skills            30.6    23.2     7.4 ***     31.8         SI3100M Riverside Human Capital Development                     26.7    23.2     3.5         14.9         SI3100M  Columbus Integrated                                     27.2    23.9     3.3         13.8         SI3100M Columbus Traditional                                    28.4    23.9     4.5         18.9         SI3100M  Detroit                                                 24.7    20.9     3.7         17.8         SI3100M  Oklahoma City                                           25.3    26.0    -0.6         -2.4         SI3100M  Portland                                                35.6    29.2     6.4         21.7         SI3100M 

 


 

                                                       Table 7.5                                    Program Impacts on Total Household Income in the Last Month of Follow-Up                                                   Sample Program Control Difference  Percentage Site and Program                                   Size   Group   Group (Impact)    Change (%)                                                  Total measured household income ($)  Atlanta Labor Force Attachment                      1890     972     971     0.1        0.0     hinctot2 Atlanta Human Capital Development                   2199     992     971    21.0        2.2     hinctot2  Grand Rapids Labor Force Attachment                 1158    1325    1356   -30.9       -2.3     hinctot2 Grand Rapids Human Capital Development              1158    1289    1356   -67.7       -5.0     hinctot2  Riverside Labor Force Attachment                    1678    1409    1431   -21.6       -1.5     hinctot2   Lacked high school diploma or basic skills        1012    1381    1377     4.7        0.3     hinctot2 Riverside Human Capital Development                 1350    1431    1377    53.7        3.9     hinctot2  Columbus Integrated                                  728    1153    1219   -66.0       -5.4     hinctot2 Columbus Traditional                                 723    1211    1219    -8.4       -0.7     hinctot2  Detroit                                              426    1166    1124    42.3        3.8     hinctot2  Oklahoma City                                        511    1173    1307  -133.4      -10.2     hinctot2  Portland                                             610    1519    1442    77.0        5.3     hinctot2                                                  Total respondent income as a                                                 percentage of total household inome (%)  Atlanta Labor Force Attachment                      1890    81.5    79.4     2.0        2.5     in2phin2 Atlanta Human Capital Development                   2199    80.0    79.4     0.5        0.7     in2phin2  Grand Rapids Labor Force Attachment                 1158    69.5    69.9    -0.4       -0.5     in2phin2 Grand Rapids Human Capital Development              1158    70.3    69.9     0.4        0.6     in2phin2  Riverside Labor Force Attachment                    1678    72.8    71.2     1.6        2.3     in2phin2   Lacked high school diploma or basic skills        1012    72.6    72.2     0.4        0.6     in2phin2 Riverside Human Capital Development                 1350    70.7    72.2    -1.4       -2.0     in2phin2  Columbus Integrated                                  728    76.3    74.9     1.4        1.8     in2phin2 Columbus Traditional                                 723    74.0    74.9    -0.9       -1.2     in2phin2  Detroit                                              426    82.1    81.3     0.8        0.9     in2phin2  Oklahoma City                                        511    68.0    65.4     2.6        3.9     in2phin2  Portland                                             610    69.5    70.5    -1.0       -1.4     in2phin2                                                                                              (continued)            Table 7.5 (continued)                                           Sample Program Control Difference Percentage Site and Program                         Size   Group   Group (Impact)   Change (%)                                        Total measured household net income ($)b  Atlanta Labor Force Attachment            1890    1005    1003     1.80        0.2 hinctot3 Atlanta Human Capital Development         2199    1020    1003    16.60        1.7 hinctot3  Grand Rapids Labor Force Attachment       1158    1327    1363   -35.50       -2.6 hinctot3 Grand Rapids Human Capital Development    1158    1301    1363   -61.90       -4.5 hinctot3  Riverside Labor Force Attachment          1678    1417    1438   -21.10       -1.5 hinctot3   Lacked high school diploma or basic     1012    1392    1386     5.90        0.4 hinctot3 Riverside Human Capital Development       1350    1435    1386    49.10        3.5 hinctot3  Columbus Integrated                        728    1181    1249   -67.60       -5.4 hinctot3 Columbus Traditional                       723    1242    1249    -7.00       -0.6 hinctot3  Detroit                                    426    1161    1127    33.90        3.0 hinctot3  Oklahoma City                              511    1201    1338  -137.80      -10.3 hinctot3  Portland                                   610    1532    1453    78.90        5.4 hinctot3