This brief was designed to assess the current state of citizen review panels (CRPs). Key findings include:
- Required by the Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment Act (CAPTA), CRPs examine child welfare policies, practices, and selected cases to evaluate whether child welfare agencies effectively protect children from maltreatment. The CRPs recommend ways to improve child protection systems, issue annual reports, and increase the accountability of and public involvement in child welfare services.
- There are at least 683 CRPs across the country, with 17 states having more CRPs than required (11 states are required to have at least one CRP, and 41 are required to have three).
- This brief found information on 119 CRPs. Fifty-six CRPs reported the use of an existing group (such as a child fatality review board, advisory group, or Children’s Justice Act task force) to meet the requirement for a CRP.
- CRP membership varies by the focal topic of the panel. Members often include state or county social services administrators, legal or judicial representatives, community social services agencies, and medical care representatives. Of the 59 reports that included information about member roles, at least 14 states indicated their panels included foster care alumni.
- CRPS are required to meet quarterly. Thus, 683 CRPs meet at least 2,677 times in a year (equivalent to over 7 CRP meetings each day of the year), with costs covered by CAPTA grants or state funds.
- CRPs commonly collect information to guide their recommendations by reviewing child protection agencies’ policies and practices and state child protection laws, holding meetings or interviews with child protection staff and administrators, and reviewing individual cases.
- CRPs often evaluate adherence to child protection standards, but no CRP reported assessing adherence to all parts of the state’s CAPTA plan.
- Most CRPs’ reports included recommendations for the state child welfare agency (98 CRPs, 82 percent). State responses suggested that states had already implemented or were planning to implement the majority of recommendations. The primary reason a state would not implement a recommendation was that legislation, policies, programs, or resources already existed to address the recommendation, making it somewhat unnecessary.
- After 30 years, there is limited information on the effectiveness of CRPs. Given the expense and time commitment of operating panels, and the presence of other oversight mechanisms, it is worth exploring whether the benefit justifies the continued cost.
*This content is in the process of Section 508 review. If you need immediate assistance accessing this content, please submit a request to Amanda Benton, Amanda.Benton@hhs.gov. Content will be updated pending the outcome of the Section 508 review.